...A fascinating and thought-provoking study of the Anglo-French naval and political relationship during the late 1930's... - Warship 2017 From Versailles to Mers-el-K bir does not settle all historiographic debate as to the effectiveness and broader strategic goals of Anglo-French naval cooperation between 1919 and 1940. What it does is provide a valuable overview of that cooperation from ... Read morea French perspective.... Melton adds a strongly pro-French interpretation to the extant literature, and a necessary interpretive framework to any discussion of naval relations in the interwar era.
H-War From Versailles to Mers el-K bir details the sometimes fruitful, often turbulent relationships between British and French statesmen and navy officials during international naval conferences in the period between the two world wars. The book details with precision and considerable relevance the differing perceptions regarding the danger posed by confrontation with Germany and Italy. Based on numerous archival sources, this is a valuable reference work that advances the knowledge of all readers who wish to understand the period in terms of diplomatic relations and naval strategy.
Herv Grall, co-author of La M moire de Mers el-K bir, president of the Association of Former Sailors and Families of the Victims of Mers el-K bir From Versailles to Mers el-K bir is a clear and compelling account of Anglo-French naval relations leading up to the tragic surprise attack on French naval units by their erstwhile British allies in July 1940. Melton has given voice to the French perspective in a balanced history that fills a long-standing gap in the literature and gives proper weight to the post-World War I renaissance of France's Marine Nationale. His work advances our understanding of how great nations work together and how, sometimes, they don't to great cost of all concerned. From Versailles to Mers el-K bir is a real eye opener and is especially relevant in today's environment where coalitions are the basis of all military and diplomatic action.
Vincent P. O'Hara, author of Torch: North Africa and the Allied Path to Victory Naval Review readers will be able to imagine what it would be like to be commanded to turn suddenly on allied ships with which they have been working harmoniously. Whether they sympathise with Churchill, Pound or Darlan, they will have to admit that Melton makes a good case in this excellent book particularly in his criticisms of British appeasement policies and the ignorance of the political elite about strategic realities.
The Naval Review (UK) Professor Melton's study of Anglo-French naval relations between World War I and into the Second World War is outstanding in its careful research and judgments.
Larry H. Addington, head, department of history (Ret.), The Citadel In the vast outpouring of studies on the Second World War and its origins, little attention has been paid to Anglo-French naval relations. Dr. Melton's admirable study, drawing as it does on both British and French archival sources, goes far to rectify this oversight.
Naval History Book Reviews The Anglo-French naval relationship remains one of the most important, and less well-understood, alliances of the twentieth century. George Melton's excellent study sheds light on this relationship's successes and troubles during the interwar era and offers important new perspectives on the alliance's famous ups and downs during the war itself. It is vital for anyone who wants to know more about the war at sea during World War II, the Mediterranean's wild history, and how navies cooperate in alliances.
Jon Hendrickson, author of Crisis in the Mediterranean: Naval Competition and Great Power Politics, 1904-1914 Show Less