The brilliance of Elizabeth: The Forgotten Years lies in the energy of its narrative, as well as in Guy's eye and ear for scene and conversation. To interweave all of this with the life of the queen is a formidable achievement. He has captured the complexity of contemporary politics. ... Most striking is Guy's portrait of Elizabeth
Stephen Alford ... Read more
London Review of Books
Significant, forensic and myth-busting, John Guy inspires total confidence in a narrative which is at once pacy and rich in detail
Anna Whitelock
Times Literary Supplement
Oft portrayed as fierce, this reveals an Elizabeth I who is in fact fallible and insecure
New Day
A fresh, thrilling portrait
Stacy Schiff
New York Times
Meticulously researched and highly readable revisionist biography. Recommended for lovers of British history and feminist biography
Library Journal
The dean of living Tudor-era historians
Christian Science Monitor
With the remarkable advantage of access to long-buried and misfiled primary sources [...] the aging monarch receives a balanced treatment. [Gives] readers a fuller view of the confident, experienced, and adaptable queen
Publishers Weekly
Outstanding. This page-turning book is history, biography, scholarship personified, and a crystal-clear look at Elizabeth in the war years that erases the myths and presents the real woman. Absolutely one of the best biographies of Elizabeth ever
Kirkus (starred review)
Guy is exceptionally good on how various myths took root
Craig Brown
Mail on Sunday
Enthralling... the book is also beautifully illustrated
Editor's Choice, The Bookseller
There is a lot to like about this book. Energetic [in] tone... Guy is a lively guide ... Guy is especially good when describing the political machinations of Burghley and Walsingham ... [and] Guy gives us a clean sense of a man [the Earl of Essex] who was brilliant, vain, petulant and self-serving in equal measure
History Today
Superb ... John Guy persuades us that pretty much everything we think we know about Elizabeth is wrong
Andrew Roberts
Wall Street Journal
John Guy, as eminent a Tudor historian as they come, has set himself the explicit task of correcting Strachey's colourful narrative of Elizabeth's old age. The result is 400 pages of outstandingly documented scholarly detail ... scholarship that should earn the respect of popular and expert reader alike
Kate Maltby
Spectator
What emerges from the author's great efforts to mine the archives for a truer picture is a more flawed Elizabeth - but perhaps a more human one
The Economist
[A] most excellent biography. It puts a cruel but clarifying lends on the vain monarch's twilight years. She has never been more exposed than in Guy's tome. A contender for history book of the year
John Lewis-Stempel
Sunday Express
Guy pored through 250,000 manuscripts in his quest to understand the ageing Elizabeth. Intimidated by that mountain of parchment, most historians have tended to recycle the myths of Gloriana and Good Queen Bess. Not Guy. Guy is no ordinary historian. Few can match his ruthless obsession for accuracy. Between every line comes whispered reassurance: You can trust me; I touched those documents. Guy the scholar melds perfectly with Guy the storyteller. Small tales are used to illustrate big issues. Under the weight of Guy's scrutiny, familiar myths crumble. The weight of evidence suggests that he understands Elizabeth better than any historian has
Gerald DeGroot
Book of the Week, The Times
John Guy is arguably the world's leading expert on Tudor history. When he writes a book, especially this, his first on Elizabeth's life, it should be taken very seriously as having something new to say, and so it does ... a wonderful book and a magisterial account of the latter half of Elizabeth's reign that calmly reassesses every claim and myth by simply reading all the original manuscript correspondence. The result puts the record straight, but it also allows Guy to produce a pacy and compelling story
Jerry Brotton
Sunday Times
One of the very best historians we have in the country. Guy is in his element prising off the myths that are barnacled to the queen. It is brilliant, vigorous history, and a triumph of storytelling and scholarship
Jessie Childs
Telegraph
As you'd expect from John Guy, this is a very good read, a vivid and fascinating warts-and-all portrait of the ageing Elizabeth, backed by meticulous research
Claire Tomalin John Guy's Elizabeth presents a beautifully rounded portrait of both the woman and the queen. Thanks to Guy's prodigious use of previously untapped material, we see, for the very first time, the full panoply of ambition and insecurity, plotting and deceit that marked the middle years of her reign. This is a masterful biography.
Amanda Foreman A gripping story of Queen Elizabeth's last years, authoritatively researched and engagingly recounted by the leading Tudor historian of our age. It will be of special interest to anyone interested in the political world in which Shakespeare's Elizabethan drama is steeped-from anxiety over royal succession to England's costly war in Ireland
James Shapiro, author of 1599 and 1606 The best biography ever written of the Virgin Queen - a revisionist, sensitive, compelling, majestic masterwork that you can't put down
Simon Sebag-Montefiore
Evening Standard
Guy's careful work with documents known and unknown, scattered throughout Europe's archives, allows him to paint a novel portrait of a complex - maybe even unknowable - queen
John Gallagher
Guardian
One of the very best historians we have in the country . . . It is brilliant, vigorous history, and a triumph of storytelling and scholarship
Jessie Childs
Telegraph
A gripping story of Queen Elizabeth's last years, authoritatively researched and engagingly recounted by the leading Tudor historian of our age
James Shapiro, author of 1599 and 1606 A beautifully rounded portrait of both the woman and the queen . . . This is a masterful biography.
Amanda Foreman Show Less