A compulsively readable story that starts as a conventional murder mystery and morphs, by degrees, into a horrifying supernatural thriller
Guardian
A huge amount of horrible fun
Big Issue
In this chilling exploration of madness and evil, Pinborough excels at summoning up the bleak spirit of Victorian London's mean streets and those forced to fight for survival there
Publisher's Weekly
The grim atmosphere of fear and spiritual malaise afflicting London is evoked well
SFX Magazine
A taut historical crime/horror that grasps you from the first page and holds you inexorably. If you enjoy John Connolly's blend of the supernatural and crime, then don't miss this!
Sci-Fi Bulletin
This is deliciously inventive stuff, delivered with the narrative nous and sense of atmosphere that lifts Mayhem above the raft of many similar novels
Crime Time
The supernatural element adds atmosphere in the way Conan Doyle used the spectral beast in The Hound of the Baskervilles. A novel, by the way, in whose company this excellent book belongs
Crime Fiction Lovers
Fantastic without caveat . . . wholly absorbing Victorian horror with just enough of the ordinary about it to set the extraordinary off
Tor.com
A very well-crafted chiller ... Pinborough successfully manoeuvres her story away from well-worn territory for a highly entertaining blend of crime procedural and Gothic horror
SciFi Now
A bloody cracking thriller that sucks you in and spits you back out!
So Many Books, So Little Time
A brilliant supernatural horror novel, served by a sense of delicacy and understatement. Her handling of the period is superb
Spooky Reads
When writing a murder mystery/thriller, there is a fine line that one has to tread. Fortunately, Mayhem treads that fine line well
Starburst
With breathless pacing, sinister suspense, and plenty of shocking twists, this is a perfect read for historical fiction and true-crime fans
Off the Shelf
Bloody brilliant!
Stephen king on Behind Her Eyes