Levine has done the readers of this book an important service in two ways. She has captured with enormous sensitivity an interesting part of American Jewish history. At the same time, she has provided students of sociology with a rich case study that demonstrates the intersection of social networks and the nature of ethnic identity.
Jewish Book World
... Read moreLike a sociological Proust, Levine has rescued an extraordinary story from the edge of oblivion. The tale of how rural German Jews succeeded in escaping the clutches of the Third Reich and reestablished a familiar world in rural New York has the plot elements that a novelist would envy. Yet, remarkably, it also has much to tell us about how immigrants construct worlds of meaning that blend aspects of their former and current homes, while ingeniously exporting the few niches that social and economic structures leave open to them. Levine tells the story with great sensitivity to the human pain and creativity it reveals and with a wonderful eye for the multiple layers of sociological explanation it requires.
Richard Alba, Vice President, American Sociological Association Tracing the transplantation of this unexpected occupation, Levine uses her case of refugees from Nazi Germany to deliver all sorts of novel insights into processes of immigration and adaptation, political economy and social identity. History, fieldwork, and theory are fused to produce global ethnography at its very best.
Michael Burawoy, University of California at Berkeley A book about Jewish cattle dealers in upstate New York? What will sociologists think to write about next? Yet, it's a wonderful story and an instructive one - about refugees who reconstructed their lives by finding a niche in the American economy and thereby surviving, economically, and culturally. Rhonda Levine doesn't forget that women were half the story. Try it; you'll enjoy it, and you'll learn from it.
Immanuel Wallerstein, Fernand Braudel Center, Yale University Sophisticated and satisfying. By depicting the variables of social structure, class, and gender, as well as past group historical experience and contemporary historical reality that need to be considered when trying to understand immigrant socioeconomic adaptation and identity formation, Levine has made a singular contribution to understanding immigrant and ethnic mobility. All academic levels.
B. Kraut, CUNY Queens College
CHOICE
Levine's study of German-Jewish cattle dealers is a richly researched and lively report on an unusual ethnic community and an invaluable addition to the fields of ethnic rural sociology and Jewish community studies. Class, Networks, and Identity is a rare gem of a book as Levine follows an ethnic population from its community of origin through emigration and immigration to acculturation and dissolution.
Herbert J. Gans, Robert S. Lynd Professor Emeritus of Sociology, Columbia University; author of Making Sense of America A valuable contribution to the ethnography of American Jewry and the sociology of immigration processes. The book is well-written, tightly organized, and accessible, and it will be a useful case study for scholars and teachers in rural sociology, immigration studies, and Jewish studies.
Contemporary Sociology
A valuable contribution to the ethnography of American Jewry and the sociology of immigration process. Levine has created a valuable picture of an immigrant experience previously neglected by sociological studies. The book is well-written, tightly organized, and accessible, and it will be a useful case study for scholars and teachers in rural sociology, immigration studies, and Jewish studies.
Community, Environment, and Population
It is an interesting work.
Journal of American Ethnic History
A well-researched and engagingly presented study. An interesting and useful study that historians and sociologists of immigration should add to their collections. It will also be of interest to students of gender relations and to those seeking to link different-level dimensions of social life in their analysis.
American Journal of Sociology
Show Less