A gripping and readable account... a thought-provoking book that more than meets the challenge of moving on from Gibbon.
SALON - the Society of Antiquaries of London Online Newsletter
[T]he major strength of the book: an absolute lack of shyness with taking positions in the field's historiographical debates...I strongly recommend this book for classroom use, particularly to ... Read morehelp students realize the impact of recent archaeology on the study of the late antique past. Moreover, Christie does not shy away from offering alternative interpretations of the same sets of evidence, with very instructive results and insights into the challenges of using archaeological data...All in all, the strength of The Fall of the Western Roman Empire is its constant movement between overarching historiographical themes and snapshots of archaeological and literary evidence which leads readers into a strong engagement with central issues of late antique history.
Damián Fernández, Northern Illinois University
Bryn Mawr Classical Review
A title that delivers in terms of bringing archaeology much more to the fore in discussion of the decline and fall of Roman provinces in the West across the 3rd and 6th centuries.
Medieval Archaeology
A well researched and thoughtful book, as is to be expected from a scholar of [Christie's] standing ... He succeeds in presenting the divergent data without simplifying the complexity of possible interpretations, discussing not only the possibilities but also the limits of the combination of historical and archaeological material. Carefully and critically done, the combination provides a much deeper understanding of the period.
Ralf Bockmann, German Archaeological Institute, Rome, Italy
The Classical Review
Accompanied by a helpful series of maps, this overview of the decline of Roman influence in the West is an extremely readable introduction to a complex, much-debated part of history, weaving together the latest archaeological evidence with historical material. Christie’s comments on the great diversity of religious beliefs under the Empire, as well as cultural changes brought by ‘barbarian’ invaders and the coming of Christianity are particularly insightful. A useful purchase for anyone studying this game-changing period of world history.
World Archaeology
[The author's] synthesis offers a useful introduction to recent archaeological research regarding the Roman West in the third through sixth centuries and to many of the interpretative questions that this period raises. It deserves to be widely read and debated.
Bailey Young, Eastern Illinois University, USA
Journal of Late Antiquity
This is a valuable book providing a solid perspective of the archaeology of the Western Roman Empire in Late Antiquity; I learnt much, as will my students, who I will certainly be directing towards this volume
David Petts, Durham University, UK
Landscape History, vol. 35
Show Less