Fogarty's study forms a nice addition to the study of modern European imperialism, and it should also be of interest to students of modern French military history. Choice This subtle and extraordinarily informative book explores the interaction of republican ideology and race... This is an elegant and well-argued study that deserves wide circulation, in the classroom and beyond.
Leonard V. Smith American Historical Review The author presents a fresh picture of how France dealt with these tensions while fighting and winning a total war.
Len Shurtleff Western Front Association Fogarty's success in illustrating the 'curious blend of tolerance and intolerance, the tension between republicanism and racism, that marked France's approach to colonial subjects in its army' ensures that readers interested in France and in the history of colonial relations will appreciate this excellent book.
Kelly Duke Bryant Journal of Colonialism and Colonial History Fogarty provides readers with a solid review of the challenges of war, human rights, and colonialism in a very readable and well-documented book.
David C. Bennett Parameters Through his meticulous research, the breadth of his study's scope, and his valuable comparative perspective, Fogarty has made an ambitious and enduring contribution to the literature about the French use of colonial peoples during the First World War.
Joe Lunn War in History Fogarty... contributes greatly to our understanding of the Great War, colonial policies and French beliefs about the indigenous other.
Brett A. Berliner Journal of Intercultural Studies In his clearly written and well-researched book, Richard Fogarty explains French notions of race and nation by examining French policies toward the half million African and Asian men deployed as troops in Europe during World War I.
Lorelle D. Semley Journal of World History A well-written, carefully argued study that advances in significant ways our understanding of the important place of empire in the Great War... It is a sad but important tale that needed to be told, and Richard Fogarty has told it well.
Martha Hanna French Politics, Culture & Society An impressive achievement, one that both supports and advances the historiography of colonial and postcolonial France. H-France Fogarty's principal strength lies in pointing out that, while racism frequently prevailed, the assimilationist ideal always played a role, and that French officers would always have to respond to it. Showing this basic ambivalence in French culture helps correct a picture, in which racism is often too easily regarded as the only criterion to define relations between Non-Europeans and Europeans in the French Empire.
Alexander Keese Journal of Military History A welcome and significant contribution to the history of these contradictions and their legacies in modern France by examining how French attempts to integrate colonial troops into the French Army during World War I deployed ideas about racial difference and in the process exposed the contradictions of the republican model.
Laura Levine Frader Journal of Interdisciplinary History This is a book about both the promise and the shortcomings of French republican ideals... A vivid portrait of the questions raised by the use of colonial troops in the war.
Mary Dewhurst Lewis French History Fogarty pays particular attention to the experience and opinions of the soldiers themselves. This is, in itself, a significant achievement. Journal of Modern History Everyone who wishes to know more about France's complex relations with its colonial subjects and their influence on current French reality should read War and Race in France.
Ruth Ginio First World War Studies