"Freedman weaves together an erudite cultural history with obvious implications for our own age of commonplace random violence."
Publishers Weekly "Freedman branches out into the world of ideas, persuasively connecting the debate about the poisoned wine to rationalism to rationalism and the problem of evil, the relationship between Enlightenment and religion, and the interpretation of historical evidence itself. Along the way, ... Read morehowever, he never loses grip of a strong narrative thread featuring sinister happenings [and] political intrigue. A Poisoned Chalice is the real thing an elegantly organized and impressively readable book by a talented historian."
Christopher Tayler, The Sunday Telegraph "Freedman's witty and well-told story lays out Zurich's bizarre criminal justice system in the context of the era's religious, political and philosophical tensions, and offers fascinating speculations on crime and radical evil."
Lev Raphael, Detroit Free Press "Freedman's detective work takes the reader on an extraordinary journey. He moves with great elegance and skill from the politics of Zurich to the wider world of the German Enlightenment: his book is a tour de force."
Joachim Whaley, Times Literary Supplement "Mr. Freedman is a historian who has a lively, thought-provoking style, and who is not afraid to risk a judgement... [He] has a real passion for the important issues at stake here."
Nigel Williams, Daily Telegraph "This book is an insightful work of microhistory that should rank with Carlo Ginzburg's The Cheese and the Worms and Natalie Zemon Davis's The Return of Martin Guerre."
Robert Anchor, American Historical Review "In addition to exploiting a good mystery's appeal to readers ... Freedman crafts his story to address serious intellectual issues... The book that results is both entertaining and intellectually stimulating
imagine, if you will, a Name of the Rose based on real sources."
Randolph C. Head, Central European History "The story itself is a rollicking good one, filled with colorful characters... The author's breezy prose keeps the story rolling along and his narrative choices preserve the mystery of a good whodunit... Freedman's bold interpretation of the Enlightenment and his successful repositioning of arguments about radical evil to the center of debate are breathtaking achievements. They are also, in their implication, profoundly disturbing."
Mary Lindeman, Journal of Modern History Show Less