Honorable Mention for the 2015 PROSE Award in Law & Legal Studies, Association of American Publishers [F]ascinating and learned.
Louis Menand, New Yorker Baldwin quite ably and thoroughly illuminates the history of copyright developments in Europe and the US.
Mark A. Fischer, Los Angeles Review of Books Baldwin expertly and economically records the major beats of copyright ... Read morehistory in the last 300 years in a surprisingly focused, readable narrative... In discussions ranging from the origins of copyright in 18th-century England, through the rise of 'moral rights' in Europe and the transition of the U.S. from global pirate to a net exporter of cultural works in the 19th century, to present day battles over Google Book Search and thorny legislation, such as the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA), Baldwin both illuminates the past and neatly sketches the contours of the battles to come.
Publishers Weekly starred review Scholarly but accessible and lucid; essential for students or modern intellectual property law and of much interest to a wide audience of writers, journalists, publishers and 'content creators'.
Kirkus Baldwin has provided an often fascinating account of debates over intellectual property, including the defense of the moral rights of authors in Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany. Most important, Baldwin makes a compelling case that although claims to intellectual property have strengthened over the last three hundred years, they do not rest in nature. Intellectual property is, in fact, 'a contingent, socially created right, in thrall to what the lawmakers of the day' decide it is.
Huffington Post The overriding value of The Copyright Wars is ... its rich history of copyright and its underlying philosophy. In particular, [Baldwin] provides a fascinating analysis of the rivalry between the US and UK conception of property rights and the continental European belief in the author's moral rights.
John Gapper, Financial Times Well-researched ... full of informative and occasionally amusing history on international treaties, ideas about authorship, and why the French get so angry when we colorize old movies. A book like Baldwin's is long overdue.
Robert Levine, Columbia Journalism Review [A]n epic history of copyright and authors' rights.
Mike Holderness, New Scientist An excellent, scholarly study of what has gone wrong with American copyright law in the last half-century that will contribute to the ongoing debate on reforming the law.
Library Journal, starred review I hardly exaggerate when I say that the story leaves the reader breathless. It is not only that the range of the author's erudition is as broad as the back of a Volga boatman, but that this book succeeds in reflecting, in its tiny puddle of a specialized subject, much of what has happened in Western thinking since the French Revolution. I cannot do it justice in a brief review, because every page is a veritable kaleidoscope of historical fact, astute ratiocination, and counterintuitive paradox, a pattern as dazzling as it is bewitching.
Andrei Navrozov, Chronicles Baldwin's detailed scholarship is second to none, and he offers a meticulously researched summary and synthesis of these debates that manages to make sense out of three centuries of legal and political struggle. The work manages to make this struggle accessible and comprehensible to a broad audience, without sacrificing any of the important nuance and context that an understanding of the issues requires.
Hans Rollman, PopMatters Copyright Wars is worth a read. It reminds readers that whereas many of today's copyright issues have to do with new technology, they have deep historical and cultural roots. And the book offers one of the best collections of copyright anecdotes.
Economist [A] superb book for the general reader.
Barney Sherman, Iowa Public Radio Peter Baldwin brilliantly unpicks the history, in this well-written, highly readable book... I never expected to call a book on copyright legislation 'fascinating'!
Tom Wilson, Information Research Baldwin has a case to make... an original and counterintuitive argument that could, if accepted, change the shape of conflicts over intellectual property (IP) in generaI... If he is right, then the way in which we see the politics of globalization in the information economy needs to be radically revised... Baldwin makes use of sources in all these countries' languages that will be largely new to the Anglophone community. Thanks to this, he is able to bring a valuable and genuinely new perspective to bear on the topic... In the end, this is an important book that deserves the attention of readers interested in cultural policy, globalization, and IP debates. The argument it makes is significant and deserves to be addressed, not so much by historians as by legal experts, digital activists, authorities in international politics, and even negotiators engaged in the nitty-gritty of trade diplomacy.
Adrian Johns, H-Net [A] superbly researched, well-written tract on how copyright developed in England, France, Germany, and the US with a view to the moral rights of authors of creative products, the role of the potential audience, and how legislation reflects the extent of the coercive ability of the state to limit an author's personal expressive ability.
Choice Peter Baldwin's The Copyright Wars: Three Centuries of Trans-Atlantic Battle ... traces the swings of power and interest between authors and their audiences in the long struggle between copyright and access. It sparkles with Baldwin's characteristic qualities: caustic and epigrammatic prose, a forensic comparative approach to differences between the US and Europe, scorn for vested interests and sloppy thinking. It has a special relevance today when corporate rights-owners are seeking in law to extend their ownership of culture in perpetuity and digital activists (and, now, academics) are fighting for open access.
Peter Mandler, History Today Copyright Wars is an enlightening read ... it provides three centuries of context to today's battles of further harmonization of copyright law in the European Union, litigious heirs of copyright works and the attempts of policymakers and judges to play catch-up with the latest technology. With MEP Julia Reda's Report on the Information Society Directive 2001/29 even suggesting copyright registration, it may be that Baldwin's historical analysis is in fact an indicator of the future direction of international copyright regulation.
Journal of Intellectual Property Law and Practice The Copyright Wars is an exhaustively researched epic journey through the international, historical, and present-day relationships among society, authors, disseminators ... and the public. It presents not only the main legal developments in sweeping history over hundreds of years ... but also a dazzling assemblage of anecdotes, historical context, quotes from obscure writings, miniutiae and 'you are there' reports on benchmark cases. Perhaps because he is a nonlawyer writing a book of social/legal history, Baldwin is free to observe and write more like a time-travelling historical journalist, unafraid to use catchy phrases or to challenge his readers.
California Lawyer In the end, this is an important book that deserves the attention of readers interested in cultural policy, globalization, and IP debates. The argument it makes is significant and deserves to be addressed ... by legal experts, digital activists, authorities in international politics, and even negotiators engaged in the nitty-gritty of trade diplomacy.
Adrian Johns, H-Net Reviews The Copyright Wars is an exhaustively researched epic journey through the international, historical, and present day relationships among society, authors, disseminators and the public. It presents not only the main legal developments in sweeping history over hundreds of years focusing on Britain, the United States, and continental Europe-but also a dazzling assemblage of anecdotes, historical context, quotes from obscure writings, minutiae, and 'you are there' reports on benchmark cases.
Corey Field, California Lawyer [T]his is an important book that deserves the attention of readers interested in cultural policy, globalization, and IP debates. The argument it makes is significant and deserves to be addressed.
Adrian Johns, H-Net Reviews [A] powerful book... This book deserves a wide readership, not just among librarians, but among those who care about corporate control of our cultural heritage.
Michael O. Eshleman, Law Library Journals Baldwin has produced an enjoyable, persuasive, and comprehensive account of a vast and complex set of historical developments. He succeeds in showing that today's 'digital generation' is fighting a battle that 'stretches back three centuries.'
Robert Spoo, Journal of Modern History Show Less