Winner of the 2008 J. David Greenstone Award, Politics and History Section of the American Political Science Association Winner of the 2008 C. Herman Pritchett Award, Law and Courts Section of the American Political Science Association "Filled with numerous examples and insightful analysis, Political Foundations of Judicial Supremacy offers a fascinating behind-the-scenes guide to the politics of judicial review that ... Read moreis impressive in both scope and depth."
Harvard Law Review "The book has the depth and breadth of scholarship that we have come to expect from Whittington. He draws on a rich study of history to support a thesis that builds from various literatures in political science generally and the study of courts in particular. Whittington writes with clarity, precision and grace and should be read, if only as a model of what scholarly work should be... Whittington makes an important contribution to our understanding of the development of American political institutions and raises interesting questions about the shape those institutions might take."
Kenneth Ward, The Law and Politics Book Review "Whittington has written a marvelous book that challenges two axioms of American political thought; the assumed constitutional basis of judicial supremacy and the Marbury 'myth' of judicial review. What distinguishes Whittington's effort from a thousand other analyses of the Court's place in American constitutional practice is his embrace of an explicitly political, as opposed to legalistic, approach to the subject."
M. E. Bailey, Choice "Whittington's masterful account captures a hidden, selfish dynamic of constitutional politics."
Aziz Huq, New York Law Journal "In his wonderfully written and insightful analysis of constitutional review and judicial supremacy in the United States, Keith Whittington takes the reader on a historical journey from the earliest years of the nation through the present day. Through his examination, Whittington provides ample evidence in support of his thesis that it is not so much the United States Supreme Court that has laid claim to judicial supremacy in constitutional interpretation as it is the elected branches of government and the executive, in particular, that have seen it in their own interest to assert that the Court is the ultimate authority on the Constitution."
Christine L. Nemacheck, Perspectives on Politics "[T]his book stands out as the best and most sophisticated study of the problem of 'who interprets' in the American context."
Walter Murphy, Law and History Review "Whittington's book is a perfect fit for both undergraduate and graduate courses on judicial process, constitutional law and theory, and jurisprudence... Whittington continues to demonstrate why he is one of today's most important constitutional scholars. Political Foundations of Judicial Supremacy is essential reading for anyone interested in American politics. Meticulously researched, grounded in the scholarly literature, yet accessible to the nonacademic, the author's arguments are important for anyone seeking an understanding of how the presidency, Congress, and the Supreme Court interact to construct constitutional meaning."
Artemus Ward, Congress & the Presidency "Whittington's book explores a fascinating issue and provides a variety of insights into the relationship between presidents the Supreme Court."
R. Shep Melnick, Journal of Politics Show Less