"Dickstein paints in broad strokes, providing brief biographical portraits of a diverse group of writers and their cultural moments. The essays on Bellow and Fitzgerald are especially fine... The ability of the imagination to constitute an interpretable but nevertheless real world is, for Dickstein, the core of literary work."
The New Yorker "Moving from Melville to Bellow, from Wharton to Roth, ... Read moreDickstein follows the novel's progress and the trends of literary theory to show that every period produces a literature that reflects something essential about the age."
Ron Charles, Washington Post Book World "A firm traditionalist, Dickstein takes issue with deconstructive theorists, who see literature as a separate, self-referential world of language, and with new historicists who deny fiction its integrity by grounding it too stubbornly in a social context that may not be relevant to the writer's purposes...The best pieces engage in a quirky and personal way with their subjects."
Madeleine Minson, Times Higher Education Supplement "Beginning with how American writers like Whitman, Melville, Wharton, Ellison and Bellow variously depicted life in New York City, literary critic Dickstein examines an array of authors in relation to their historical moments and explores the significance of how they represented their worlds... [He] makes a case for the social awareness of F. Scott Fitzgerald's late, Depression-era writing, and reflects on the notion of alienation, and on the enigmatic sensibilities of Kafka and Beckett."
Publishers Weekly "Blending cultural history and literary biography with the barest traces of memoir, Dickstein has produced in his newest essay collection that rarest of species of literary criticism: one as genial to the general reader as to the academic."
Library Journal "Twenty illuminating essays ... on literature's elusive, prophetic interpretations of a changing American society... A fine, accessible collection."
Kirkus Reviews "If Mr. Dickstein were a less intelligent critic, his book might be more aggressively polemical. As it is, what he offers is ... a series of thoughtful studies. The book makes one envy Mr. Dickstein's students who get to be introduced to these writers ... by a critic of such warm and varied sympathies. And even an experienced reader will make some new acquaintance in these pages."
Adam Kirsch, The New York Sun "[An] admirable new collection of critical essays... [E]very page in the volume displays curiosity, incision and surprise."
Ilan Stavans, Forward "A particular strength of this volume is its deft combination of historical and formal reading practices; Dickinson brings together literature's social and aesthetic registers to produce insightful discussion of canonical authors... A strong contribution to American literary criticism."
Choice "Good news is at hand, and Morris Dickstein's new book is an example of it. He actually enjoys talking with us about literature, here mainly the novel."
Jeffrey Hart, National Review "Dickstein wants to show that the real world counts, and suffuses fictions... Weve learned ... to see Stendhal better and to regard novels not so much as mirrors but as "prisms" with many facets that refract and refresh the world we know."
Jay Martin, Antioch Review Show Less