Prose, Volume III is wonderfully edited, like all the many editions of Auden supervised by Edward Mendelson... Most of the articles will delight any reader with their wit. charm, and elegance.
Charles Rosen, The New York Review of Books [Auden's] versatility and spikily independent literary intelligence are frequently on display in Prose, Volume Three: 1949-1955, the most recent volume ... Read morein the magnificent Complete Works.
Stefan Collini, Times Literary Supplement This latest installment of Edward Mendelson's edition of the Complete Works contains Auden's prose writings from a mere six years, roughly the poet's forties. It was preceded by two large volumes covering 1926 to 1938 and 1939 to 1948. The three total more than two thousand pages and there will have to be at least one more volume, covering the period between 1955 and Auden's death in 1973. When you add in the volumes already devoted to plays, libretti, poems, it becomes hard to avoid describing the whole enterprise as heroic. In fact it could also be described as unique, for no other 20th-century English poet has been so fully and patiently honoured.
Frank Kermode, London Review of Books This third volume of his complete prose is the best yet...Here is the ambitious set of lectures published as The Enchafed Flood, about the Romantic hero and the sea, in Melville, Baudelaire and (taken with entire seriousness) Edward Lear. Here are the influential reviews of Tolkien and the introductions to first books by Adrienne Rich and John Ashbery... No major writer's complete works are more fun to read.
Publishers Weekly (starred review) Few great and greatly prolific poets wrote as much irresistible and glorious prose as W.H. Auden but he was, by any assay, one of the greatest essayists and critics of the 20th century. And here we have Auden in his 40s, one of the greatest eras of Auden prose, the era of The Enchafed Flood, and so many of the essays collected in The Dyer's Hand.
Jeff Simon, Buffalo News With the fifth volume of his 'Complete Works' and the third of his prose out
with a fourth, and final volume promised
we can glimpse almost the full range of [Auden's] interests and his remarkable versatility...When Auden felt affinity with a subject, his prose could dazzle. His essay here on Oscar Wilde, 'A Playboy of the Western World: St. Oscar, the Hominterm Martyr,' is at once poignant and astute, as is his fine introduction to a selection of Edgar Allan Poe's writings. But the best essay may be 'Portrait of a Whig,' Auden's searching and affectionate study of the inimitable Sydney Smith (1771-1845).
Eric Ormsby, New York Sun In part the appeal of this volume derives from its author's aphoristic cast of mind, but more significant is the self-evident fact Auden was a poet first and a critic second: for all his love of lists and categories, his thought is always round, never linear. He is able to see, as only a poet can, that rules don't always apply, that they can sometimes be broken.
Oliver Dennis, The Australian Praise for previous volumes: To have found and contextualized the material collected in this second volume of Auden's prose is a magnificent achievement, and Edward Mendelson's immaculately handled edition will be a scholarly resource of a permanent kind.
Peter MacDonald, Times Literary Supplement Praise for previous volumes: This essential volume in a projected complete edition restores the voracious reader and never pedantic critic to the master poet.
Publisher's Weekly Praise for previous volumes: The Complete Works, edited with elegant scruple by Auden's literary executor Edward Mendelson is ... the only way to get at Auden as he happened, year by year, bit by bit, and not as he, or his later biographers, want us to think of him.
Tom D'Evelyn, Boston Book Review Praise for previous volumes: The collection, which can be dipped into as well as read as a whole, is a feast of language and insight.
Arthur Kirsch, Washington Post Book World Mendelson's introductions to each of the five installments so far of Auden's Complete Works have been unfailingly elegant and magisterial.
Alan Jacobs, Books & Culture This scholarly collection, with its seventy pages of notes on variant readings, revives many interesting pieces as well as numerous others of interest mainly to academics.
Larry Koenigsberg, Magill Book Reviews This excellent tomb of a book is as academic as it is entertaining as it is informative as it is inspiring as it is (obviously) superbly well written. The only downside being, it ensures the literary bar is so highly placed, it ensures the rest of us can only ever negotiate coming close
if, with the exception of a selected few, such a thing is remotely possible.
David Marx, bookreviews.davidmarx.co.uk Show Less