"Wills' work is a thoughtful analysis of an historical practice with decidedly contemporary implications."
Journal of Southern Religion "Well written, this book is a model of using church records as key sources. Important for students of southern religion and culture and American religious life more generally."
Choice ".will make a significant contribution to the field of American religious history."
Paul Harvey, Colorado College ... Read more"It is excellent, a real breakthrough in the use of local church records. His impressively documented and compelling argument brings to light the practice of Baptist 'democratic' culture during the century in which the South took shape.... Structured as it is on an imaginative exploitation of rich local Baptist records, especially in Georgia, this innovative work will be welcomed by students of American religion and Southern culture alike."
Donald G. Mathews, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill "Wills uses the prism of church discipline to examine critical questions of race, theology, the role of women, and the nature of the church as addressed by nineteenth-century Georgia Baptists. His well-written work offers a critical case study in Baptist polity and popular religion. The book is a valuable contribution to studies in grassroots Christianity in the South."
Bill J. Leonard, Wake Forest University "This important study is going to generate a lot of rethinking and debate regarding the contested history of the Southern Baptist Convention."
George Marsden, University of Notre Dame "[T]his book is an important contribution to Calvinistic Baptist life, prmarily in Georgia, during the nineteenth century."
Georgia Historical Quarterly "This is a fascinating book, characterized by detailed research...and challenging conclusions.... This book deserves a wide reading. It has a significant contribution to make."
Faith & Mission "Breaking new conceptual ground."
The Southern Quarterly "...Democratic Religion is an important revision to Hatch's work....Will's labors will go far in enabling historians to nuance the picture of Southern religion, particularly in the antebellum period."
Church History "Wills is at his best in explaining the theological roots of the disciplinary process and its function and practise within the churches. His research in the primary records is strong..."
Journal of Southern History "This book is the definitive study of nineteenth century Southern Baptist church discipline to date."
Journal of American History "Wills has produced a splendid study that should long serve as a model of how to research and to write religious history."
Baptist History and Heritage "...this book is well worth the reading time. Wills provides clear but succinct paragraphs in each chapter to explain the historical background of the issue....The book should appeal to a professional and a lay audience of Arkansans and southerners at large and indeed to anyone interested in southern history and culture."
Arkansas Historical Quarterly "Wills's work is excellent, both in its scholarship and presentation...Wills has effectively shown that most of what we think we know about Baptists in nineteenth-century America is probably not true and is certainly open to reexamination...this work is one which will appeal equally to professional scholars and the academic laity, especially anyone interested in the Baptist tradition in America."
Mississippi Quarterly Show Less