[An] illuminating, ambitious and unsentimental history... Exceptionally lucid.
Fergus M. Bordewich, Wall Street Journal [An] outstanding account of the American Civil War... This expertly written narrative will draw in anyone with an interest in the Civil War at any knowledge level.
Library Journal, starred review A genuinely fresh, persuasive perspective on the Civil War... [A Savage War] will ... Read moremake even readers with a strong knowledge of the war think about how it was fought and why it ended as it did. A winner for Civil War history buffs.
Kirkus, starred review [A] very important new history of the American Civil War by two important historians.
Newt Gingrich [A] new and interesting military history of the American Civil War.
Francis P. Sempa, New York Journal of Books The best, clearest, and most instructive military history of the Civil War I have ever read... [A Savage War] hit a home run.
Tyler Cowen, Marginal Revolution [F]or those who want to understand the key decisions that determined the outcome of the [Civil War], the organization of the opposing armies and their deployments, the role of logistics and intelligence, and the moments of inspired generalship (and missed opportunities), it is hard to imagine a better book than this.
Lawrence D. Freedman, Foreign Affairs Widely published and respected military historians Murray and Hsieh produce a fresh look at the US Civil War... An important, impressive book.
Choice Murray and Hsieh offer keen insights on the crossroads of social, political, and technological drivers that produced what the authors call the first modern war... The mini-portraits of Abraham Lincoln, Ulysses S. Grant, Robert E. Lee, and William T. Sherman sprinkled throughout that narrative are superb, and the critiques of Jeff Davis and the hapless Henry Halleck are devastating... [A] stimulating contribution to the field that will captivate readers. [A Savage War] belongs on the shelf of students of war, right next to their worn copy of McPherson's classic, Battle Cry of Freedom.
Lt. Col. F.G. Hoffman, Marine Corps Gazette Hsieh and Murray illuminate the broader political and cultural forces that shaped the [Civil War's] course while also giving due credit to the impact of contingency and human action... A Savage War will appeal to both academic and popular audiences with its resonance, accessible prose, and fresh treatment of the events that still captivate America's public consciousness over 150 years later.
Lt. Andrew L. Hargroder, Civil War Book Review Show Less