One of Choice's Outstanding Academic Titles for 2010 "It's a fascinating story... Happily, there is consolation in A Very Brief History of Eternity, hidden in plain sight... As long as God's problems with living in eternity mirror what our own would be, maybe mortality isn't so bad after all."
Andrew Stark, Wall Street Journal "Despite its heady topic, Eire's engaging style ... Read moreand sense of humor keep things light enough to carry readers through a history of 'how conceptions of forever, or eternity, have evolved in Western culture, and what role these conceptions have played in shaping our own self-understanding, personally and collectively.' Eire gives readers so much to think about and in such an entertaining manner that he can be excused for occasionally overreaching."
Publishers Weekly "Carlos Eire's A Very Brief History of Eternity reminds us that our puzzlement over what comes after death has a history. The ways in which we ask about our relation to death and the hereafter do not take place in a vacuum. Instead, our wondering arises within particular historical contexts, where life and death are related in particular ways."
Todd May, Forbes "A profound and unsettling inquiry."
Bryce Christensen, Booklist (starred review) "A lively trot around the literature, referring to everything from the Reformation to ghosts to Karl Marx to tattooing, in the company of a skeptical believer. A tough topic tamed by a lively mind."
Miriam Cosic, Australian "Eire intimately addresses the weighty subject of eternity in this delightful volume. His skill at engaging readers conceals the rigorous, thoughtful research and methodology that went into this volume... As it stands this thought-provoking book is sure to be a classic."
Choice "Eire is an avuncular companion. While his subject may be beyond comprehension, Eire himself is imminently accessible and genuinely concerned for the reader's edification. And his dashes of humor, witty and sharp, are a welcoming leavening to a sometimes heavy read. Yet this book is ideal for lovers of The Big Idea, people who enjoy an author's attempt at explaining something they always thought about but didn't know what questions to ask, and people who enjoy reading about the most basic things, like being and nothingness, here and eternity."
John Stoehr, New Haven Advocate "You could say that Carlos Eire goes on and on about eternity
but most of the time he does so informatively and entertainingly. And without sacrificing the intellectual rigour the subject requires."
Steven Carroll, The Age "[The book] contains many good things and is especially good on the symbiosis between understandings of eternity and the ways the dead and the living relate. It is written in a relaxed and lively style."
Paul J. Griffiths, First Things "Eire's erudite, engaging, and often witty history should interest anyone interested in Dickinson's 'Flood subject' (L319), as she called her understanding of immortality."
Barbara Kelly, EDIS Bulletin "[Eire] writes with style, wearing his erudition lightly... A Very Brief History of Eternity achieves very well what it sets out to do: to enlighten while proceeding at pace."
Reverend Dr. Andrew Davison, Church Times "A Very Brief History of Eternity ... is both erudite and entertaining. Eire's ability to explain complex ideas and to elucidate the ways in which concepts of eternity have affected the way human beings live as well as being themselves affected by human activity, have made the book popular among readers. While the topic chosen by Eire, eternity, is thought-provoking and momentous, requiring the readers' full attention, Eire saves his book from being too formidable a treatise with gentle humor and witty asides."
Shawncey Webb, Magill's Literary Annual "A history of the concept of eternity in Western thought is a brilliantly original idea, and Carlos Eire makes complex ideas easily accessible. Eire is deeply learned in history, philosophy, theology, literature, language, and popular culture... [T]his is a book that deserves a lot of attention by historians, philosophers, and theologians, and it is written so clearly that it will also interest the literate public."
Jeffrey Burton Russell, Catholic Historical Review "While his style is relaxed, he covers so much ground ... that readers will find and feel that, in its own way, the book is weighty... Eire knows that we know that one cannot think or write historically about eternity. So his book is a history of human questionings, ponderings, and sometimes foolishly or frighteningly bold dealings with the concept. What he finds and details, yes, briefly, should enrich the reflections of historians as they deal with time."
Martin E. Marty, Journal of Church History Show Less