Review of the original French edition: "The mind-blowing story of a bureaucratic utopia that turned into carnage. A 'micro-history' that forms a representative example in a country where the inconceivable became the norm."
Thomas Wieder, Le Monde "[An] absorbing new book... After detailing the lead-up to the deportation of the 'socially harmful elements' and the political situation surrounding it, Mr. Werth ... Read morezeroes in on the Nazino affair to illustrate the policy's devastating effect."
Martha Mercer, New York Sun "Few books have captured the human tragedy of Stalin's bloody reign so succinctly or with such force."
Douglas Smith, Seattle Times "Cannibal Island is a grim tale of ten thousand 'anti-social elements' deposited on an empty Siberian island in the Ob river in the 1930s. But, more than that, it is a story of how the brutal purge machinery was oiled and run at its lowest level."
Paul E. Richardson, Russian Life Magazine "Nicolas Werth's excellent history of the Nazino gulag is a portrait of a place that went from terrible to unimaginable... In a strong field, Cannibal Island is one of the grisliest and most unpleasant accounts of gulag life... This one ranks as one of the more memorable exhibits in the gallery of horrors."
Graeme Wood, Weekly Standard "This is an utterly harrowing account of the 'bloody implementation of a utopia' and an exemplary analysis of the Soviet state, with its 'number culture' and 'pseudocategorizations'
all of this underpinned, of course, by the most spectacular cruelty."
Richard King, Sydney Morning Herald "Often the details in a single instance sear more deeply than the most gruesome tally of large numbers...Werth describes in rich detail the transformation of the vast western Siberian wilderness into the dumping ground for millions of 'de-kulakized' peasants, minority groups from the borderlands, the socially marginal, criminals, and the utterly innocent...These 'special settlements' are a part of the gulag's least-known history. Werth corrects that in plain and clear language, leaving the story to convey its own excruciating eloquence."
Robert Levgold, Foreign Affairs "Nicolas Werth's book is the stuff of nightmares. It recounts the fate of 6,000 'special settlers', rounded up in Moscow and Leningrad in 1933 and sent to the island of Nazino in the Ob River in Western Siberia."
Carla King, Irish Times "[A] chilling piece of historical reconstruction"
London Review Bookshop "The author demonstrates encyclopedic erudition and provides nuanced explanations. Ample quotations from reports and letters of government officials give the book its sense of immediacy. In other words, the volume is both scholarly and absorbing, which is a rare combination."
Michael Jakobson, Slavic Review "In short, this remarkable case study of dysfunction and terror makes a valuable contribution to our understanding of Stalinism."
JeffreyS.Hardy, H-Net Reviews "[This book] mark[s] a quantitative leap forward in data now available in English on these important and complex problems that had previously been much neglected."
Stephen G. Wheatcroft, American Historical Review "Werth's meticulous approach to the study of social order and administrative norms in the Stalin era is likely to be of real interest to specialists in GULAG studies, camp memoirs, and Soviet culture in general. Clearly and forcefully argued, Cannibal Island does an excellent job of reconstructing the way in which Soviet officials and institutions operated in the 1930s. Readable enough to serve as a good source for undergraduates working on research papers in Soviet history and culture, this volume would make a good addition to even the most modest university library collections."
Emily D. Johnson, Slavic and East European Journal "Cannibal Island is a valuable addition to emerging Gulag scholarship in so far as it demonstrates how, in the early 1930s, this network of labour camps and settlements also began serving as a dumping ground for those elderly, destitute, and physically and mentally disabled 'elements' the regime expunged from urban centres."
Andrew A. Gentes, European History Quarterly "This short yet extraordinarily rich account of Stalinist politics and Soviet life should be read widely."
Hiroaki Kuromiya, Slavonic and East European Review Show Less