Hutchinson's study captures the complexity of nation building, with its varying, spatially bounded timelines, areas of mixed settlement, cultural traditions, and political priorities, both internal and external... (His) overarching thesis about the strength of national allegiances and the centrality of the relations of bellicose nation-states — first in Europe and then in much of the rest of the world, where ... Read more"nation state-building continues in many of the 'new wars'" (2) — is a compelling one.
Mark Hewitson, University College London, Journal of Modern History
Hutchinson provides a nuanced examination of the collapse of empires and the subsequent rise of nation-states...[His] ethno-symbolist approach pays more attention to the myth-making and commemoration rituals after wars than to the war experience itself. This results in a fascinating chapter...which deals with the role of symbols, we-they stereotypes, social rituals, commemorations, and the long-term consequences of all of these.
Eric Storm, History: Reviews of New Books, 47:3, 2019, 47-50
The comparative range of this relatively short book, the close engagement with the theoretical literature around both nationalism and the role of war in state formation, and the author's readiness to question received opinions make this a rich and rewarding study, with food for thought on every page. It will provide much material for debate in advanced level and graduate seminars, as well as among other scholars.
Andrew G. Bonnell, University of Queensland, Australian Journal of Politics and History
A quite remarkable study that in the breadth and depth of its analysis should inform any and all future debate in respect of the relationship between warfare and nationalism. Hutchinson constructs his sophisticated and superbly structured thesis on a canvas as historically deep as it is geographically broad; stretching from the Thirty Years War to Vietnam, from the Balkans to Burma.
Susan Mary Grant, Nations and Nationalism
Show Less