One of the finest park histories that I’ve read—thoughtful, original, fluidly written, meticulously researched. By juxtaposing three intertwined stories—history, archaeology, and interpretation—Moyer and Shackel explain how the quest for historical authenticity can give way to the creation of a fantastical parkscape. A superb case study on how 'history makes itself' and a model for future park histories.
R. Bruce ... Read moreCraig, former executive director, National Coalition for History More than just a meticulously researched account of the creation of an iconic American park, the authors present a human story of contested meanings, good intentions, and power politics. Why did the National Park Service demolish most of the 19th-century architecture in Harpers Ferry? Who claimed that John Brown was a lunatic? And why was one of the first of the park's historians relegated to cleaning restrooms? Read on.
Adrian Praetzellis, professor of anthropology, Sonoma State University; author of Dug to Death This is the kind of thoughtful and provoking study of shifting policy and practice that every historic site needs. Moyer and Shackel have probed beneath the surface to analyze the changing treatment and presentation over time of a complex historic place at the confluence of two majestic rivers where events occurred that propelled Americans toward the Civil War.
Richard West Sellars, author of Preserving Nature in the National Parks: A History How is history preserved, presented, and commemorated? In this book, Moyer and Shackel give us rare insight into the process of how a national park gets made. In the process we learn how the conflicting goals and differing perceptions of various stakeholders can cause the past to be changed over time. This is a superb example of multidisciplinary research at its finest, told with conviction and feeling. It's destined to become a standard text in classroom and field, and hopefully also in the halls of power. Those of us concerned about our vanishing cultural heritage need more books like this one.
Charles E. Orser Jr., Vanderbilt University Teresa S. Moyer and Paul A. Shackel help us analyze the historical reality of Harpers Ferry National Historical Park through their careful examination of the National Park Service's restoration and interpretation of this historically important place. In so doing, they emphasize two topics shared by most historic sites: restoration philosophy and multiple histories.
Dwight Pitcaithley Harpers Ferry is, to my mind, one of the most compelling historic sites in the nation. There are so many histories living in layer after layer of this place. Teresa S. Moyer and Paul A. Shackel excavate them in all their exquisite complexity, offering a model biography of a historic site.
Edward T. Linenthal, editor, Journal of American History A lovingly told story....The book is useful because it tells several neglected stories....A fine study.
.
H-Net: Humanities and Social Science Reviews Online, April 2008
Moyer and Shackel skillfully uncover the site's many layers and illuminate both its strengths and limitations as a window on the past and as a canvas for changing NPS initiatives.
Journal of Southern History, November 2008
The Making of Harpers Ferry National Historical Park is a fascinating book that is fully engaged with the present. The 'making' in the title highlights the importance of the recent past, present, and even the future in the author's perspectives. Moyer and Shackel have created a useable past by discussing the shortcomings of preservation and interpretation at the park . . . This book should be required reading for all cultural resource management professionals.
Material Culture
Show Less